Confused and All
I wouldn't have used the word Confused in the title of this blog if I were certain about things. This whole situation is confusing. I can ignore it to a point, take the easy way out and express limited outrage, then go about my day. But that wouldn't be fair. Now, I'm not under any illusion that what I say matters to anyone but myself, but for the sake of my own soul, my own cherished principals and moral world view, isn't it time I wrote about the war in Israel and in Gaza?
But it's complicated. Even using the term War means I'm taking a side. Because how can it be called a war when one side loses hundreds of people and the other loses four? How can it be called a war when one side has incredible missiles shooting off fighter jets while the other side shoots primitive rockets?
And ignoring terminology, how do I feel about it? Truth is I hear about the Hamas leader killed by Israeli missiles, and I can't feel sorry for him, because he called for suicide attacks on Israelis.
But what does that mean?
I pride myself on being a pacifist, and not just a pacifist, but an informed one, because I was in the Israeli military for three years and have earned the right to lose faith in the military and in the Israeli government. I saw death and destruction and people losing the best years of their lives for goals that could have been achieved with diplomacy years earlier. Israeli soldiers died in Lebanon for no reason. Israeli soldiers died in the West Bank and in Gaza to stop Hamas, only to watch it from a distance gain even more power when American citizens elected an idiot who insisted on Palestinian elections when conditions on the ground favored a hard-line, anti-Israeli government. And I watched strike and retaliatory strike, where civilians on both sides died in the streets and in their homes for no reason.
But I hear about the Hamas leader, and I hope he rots in hell, because my cherished pacifism can take a break for a while. And I hear about this guy's wives who died with him in the attack, and I think, Well, they knew what they were getting into. And I hear about his dead children, and I think, Isn't that a shame... Isn't war a horrible thing...
And I realize--I'm not really a pacifist. Just another fraud who had been led to believe that some people need to die, and some people don't, but die anyway, because that's the way the world is.
More to the point, because I might as well get there. I don't believe the Israeli government cares about its soldiers. I don't believe the Israeli government cares that my 7-year-old niece's school bus takes an alternative route to avoid Hamas rockets. I don't believe the Israeli government cares that the traumas of Israeli children mean another generation of hopeless dreams of peace.
Because we do this shit in Israel when we're in kindergarten. We sing songs of peace and wave the flags of all nations, and smile because we believe in our tiny selves. But we grow up to a situation that makes us think the outcome is out of our hands.
And don't get me wrong. I put more emphasis on criticizing Israel but--and I'll avoid the who's more wrong here--the world will be a better place when Hamas dismantles and its leaders descend into the hell kept for those who sacrifice the lives of the helpless among them.
And I wanted to get to the point, but now it seems like I'll just continue going in circles.
Because there's so much there.
Sure, it's tragic to see Gaza destroyed and people lying in pools of blood. But it's tragic to see Israelis die, and the difference shouldn't be about the numbers of casualties.
It's tragic to imagine my niece even thinking about the possibility of a fucking rockets hitting her school bus, but it's also tragic to imagine a generation after generation of Palestinian kids who are born to little hope and grow up to none.
And the most fucked up thing about it is that even if I manage the impossible task of being objective about it all, if on the one hand I see the that pain of four Israeli families is just as horrible as that of four hundred Palestinian families, because numbers are meaningless when you mourn a loved one; and if I see on the other hand that my niece's trauma is just as tragic as that of a Palestinian girl born into an endless war, and if I see all of these children, Israeli and Palestinian children who think their generations will fix it all, only to grow up realizing they're all just meaningless pawns in God's joke... Well, even if I see all that I still know nothing.
There's a war going on. Or maybe there isn't.
People die. Some of them deserve it. Or maybe they don't.
There will be peace in our lifetime. Or maybe there won't.







